Market leading insight for tax experts
View online issue

Have your say on the tax tribunals

printer Mail
A call for wider engagement.

Tax practitioners spend much of their time engaging with the Tax Chamber Tribunals through case-specific individual appeals. The Tax Tribunals Users Group (TTUG) provides something different. It is an opportunity, once or twice a year, for HMRC, professional representative bodies, advisers and the tribunals to discuss the user experience more broadly and to explore how the system is working in practice.

Established in its current form in 2009, the group is a forum for major stakeholders to engage with the tribunals. We serve a wide range of users and benefit from hearing directly from those who use the tribunals the most. Users also benefit from understanding our operational realities and constraints.

Prioritising engagement, transparency and improvement: Both tribunals have had new Presidents in the last 15 months, and together they have sought to place greater emphasis on engagement, transparency and continuous improvement. Both the First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal, like many parts of the justice system, face significant challenges. Users rightly expect appeals to be resolved fairly, efficiently and within a reasonable timeframe. Those objectives are not always easy to reconcile with finite judicial and administrative resources, increasing case complexity and fluctuating volumes of litigation.

Our approach is to be open and transparent about the challenges we face and the steps being taken to address them. Over the past two years, the FTT has made changes to improve efficiency and make better use of judicial resources. These include the way cases are managed and listed, and identifying appeal categories that can be resolved more quickly and proportionately. We have also explored how technology and digitisation can support better case management and communications, as well as how open justice and transparency can be strengthened through more accessible information. Our broader objective is to ensure that users understand how the tribunals operate and can have confidence in the system.

Practitioner feedback informs our approach: The objective is not simply speed for its own sake. A system that resolves appeals quickly, but at the expense of fairness, would not be successful. Equally, delay imposes costs and uncertainty on taxpayers, HMRC and representatives. The challenge is identifying processes that preserve judicial fairness, while reducing avoidable delay.

Recent TTUG meetings have included constructive discussions on listing practices, resource pressures, case management initiatives, digital developments, mediation and other approaches intended to improve the user experience. Practitioners often identify practical consequences of procedural changes that are not immediately apparent from our perspective. Those observations are valuable and regularly inform our thinking.

The meeting format is straightforward. The Presidents of both tribunals provide updates on developments within their respective chambers, followed by an open question and answer session. We generally encourage questions in advance, where possible, to ensure that any response is accurate and properly informed.

How you can contribute: By hosting online meetings, we can accommodate a broad range of participants. We would welcome wider engagement from across the tax profession. We encourage tax firms that wish to participate to nominate one or two principal contacts to the TTUG. Doing so makes it easier to circulate invitations, agendas and updates, while ensuring that information reaches those with a genuine interest in the group’s work.

The group works best when there are genuine conversations. We are keen to hear your questions, but also observations about changes that have been introduced, how those changes are working in practice and where further improvements may be possible. If you are interested in joining the group, please contact the President’s Office at presidentsofficestax@justice.gov.uk. We hope that a wider range of voices will contribute to the discussion in the months and years ahead. 

Mr Justice Thompsell, President of the Upper Tribunal Tax and Chancery Chamber, and Judge Amanda Brown KC, President of the First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber)

Issue: 1777
Categories: In brief
EDITOR'S PICKstar
Top