For supplies on or after 1 April 2027, Finance Bill 2027 contains a legislative amendment to abolish the reverse-charge regime in relation to non-UK VAT registered domestic traders. As a corollary, traders below the VAT registration threshold no longer need to count supplies received from overseas towards their registration threshold.
That being the case, it is easy to overlook that it was, in fact, always unlawful to take such supplies into account. Article 288 of the EU VAT Directive conclusively lists the types of transactions which may be taken into account when assessing whether a small business does not need to register. That list contains output supplies only.
That reverse charge supplies are considered as well under domestic law follows only from the fiction in VATA 1994 s 8(1): they are treated as if they were made by the person receiving them. But EU law knows no such fiction. Article 196 of the Directive simply provides that the recipient is liable for the VAT, without deeming it to be the supplier.
It is therefore easy to see that it is wrong under UK law to take reverse charge supplies into account. It is equally easy to see how UK law can be given a conforming interpretation, as required by FA 2024 s 28(4): the reference to ‘taxable supplies’ in the threshold provision in Sch 1 para 1(1) must simply be read as referring to actual output supplies only, without the reverse charge fiction.
Anyone facing a compulsory registration and/or VAT assessment for breaching the registration threshold only due to reverse charge supplies therefore potentially has a good defence based on the above.
The trickier question is whether those who registered in the past in good faith only due to reverse charge supplies have an avenue to reclaim any money. A potential argument could be as follows: the trader merely notified HMRC of (what it thought was) a liability to register for VAT. Where, as here, that liability never existed in the first place, that notification is of no effect: the liability either does or does not arise as a matter of law; the notification is declaratory only, unable to create a liability where otherwise there is none. As a consequence, net VAT paid under this erroneous registration can be reclaimed under VATA 1994 s 80. This argument is, however, inconsistent with Savidge v HMRC [2009] UKVAT V20972.
For supplies on or after 1 April 2027, Finance Bill 2027 contains a legislative amendment to abolish the reverse-charge regime in relation to non-UK VAT registered domestic traders. As a corollary, traders below the VAT registration threshold no longer need to count supplies received from overseas towards their registration threshold.
That being the case, it is easy to overlook that it was, in fact, always unlawful to take such supplies into account. Article 288 of the EU VAT Directive conclusively lists the types of transactions which may be taken into account when assessing whether a small business does not need to register. That list contains output supplies only.
That reverse charge supplies are considered as well under domestic law follows only from the fiction in VATA 1994 s 8(1): they are treated as if they were made by the person receiving them. But EU law knows no such fiction. Article 196 of the Directive simply provides that the recipient is liable for the VAT, without deeming it to be the supplier.
It is therefore easy to see that it is wrong under UK law to take reverse charge supplies into account. It is equally easy to see how UK law can be given a conforming interpretation, as required by FA 2024 s 28(4): the reference to ‘taxable supplies’ in the threshold provision in Sch 1 para 1(1) must simply be read as referring to actual output supplies only, without the reverse charge fiction.
Anyone facing a compulsory registration and/or VAT assessment for breaching the registration threshold only due to reverse charge supplies therefore potentially has a good defence based on the above.
The trickier question is whether those who registered in the past in good faith only due to reverse charge supplies have an avenue to reclaim any money. A potential argument could be as follows: the trader merely notified HMRC of (what it thought was) a liability to register for VAT. Where, as here, that liability never existed in the first place, that notification is of no effect: the liability either does or does not arise as a matter of law; the notification is declaratory only, unable to create a liability where otherwise there is none. As a consequence, net VAT paid under this erroneous registration can be reclaimed under VATA 1994 s 80. This argument is, however, inconsistent with Savidge v HMRC [2009] UKVAT V20972.






