Market leading insight for tax experts
View online issue

Whose loss counted? Taxation, colonialism and the debts Britain chose to honour

printer Mail
Speed read
The Slavery Abolition Act 1833 provided compensation for the loss of legally recognised interests in enslaved people, but not for the experience of enslavement. Reading its provisions alongside Mary Prince’s account, this article follows the revenue from colonial trade, the valuation and inheritance of compensation, and the public debt incurred to fund it. It asks whose losses the law recognised, and whose it left outside the settlement.
Looking back on Black History Month, Siobhan Duncan (Temple Tax Chambers) revisits an uncomfortable chapter in Britain's fiscal history: the compensation paid to slave owners following the abolition of slavery, and the absence of any comparable provision for those who had been enslaved. Her essay considers how that compensation was financed, who ultimately paid for it and what these arrangements reveal about whose losses the state chose to recognise.

Mary Prince recalled her mother dressing her and her sisters, Hannah and Dinah, on the morning they were to be sold. ‘See, I am shrouding my poor children; what a task for a mother!’ she said.

At the market, the sisters stood against a wall; Mary was first, followed by Hannah and then Dinah. Mary was sold for £57 in Bermuda currency, equivalent to approximately £38 sterling at the time. Bystanders remarked on the high price paid for a child. Her sisters were sold to different purchasers.[1]

Her account was published in 1831. Through it, readers could know something of the child behind the sale price and of the family from whom she was taken. Two years later, Parliament enacted the Slavery Abolition Act 1833 (the ‘1833 Act’), authorising £20m to compensate the loss of legally recognised interests in enslaved people rather than the experience of enslavement.[2]

Sugar and colonial power

The £57 bought a purchaser control over Mary’s work as well as her whereabouts. That control over a person’s labour lay behind the wealth of the plantation economy, some of which reached the British Exchequer through duties on colonial produce.

In Campbell v Hall (1774), James Campbell, a Grenada plantation owner, sought to recover a 4½% duty paid on sugar exports. His action against the collector was for money had and received. The Crown had already granted representative government to Grenada. Although the assembly had not yet met, that grant prevented the Crown from imposing the duty by prerogative. The court considered the duty equitable as between Grenada and the other British Leeward Islands, but that could not supply the authority to impose it. Campbell’s claim succeeded.[3]

His claim required the court to decide whether his money had been lawfully taken. The conditions under which people had produced the sugar were not before it. Their labour nevertheless helped sustain the trade from which Britain drew revenue. A study in The Journal of Economic History estimates that sugar generated approximately a third of British customs receipts from 1787 to 1818.[4]

For households buying sugar, colonial interests were present in the price. On 25 May 1829, Charles Grant, MP for Inverness-shire, challenged differential duties intended to protect West Indian producers; the Chancellor of the Exchequer resisted reductions that he expected to diminish revenue.[5] The dispute concerned both the protection of colonial producers and the income the government drew from their trade.

What the Act valued

Abolition required Parliament to decide what would become of legally recognised interests in enslaved labour. In 1833, ministers defended compensation as a means of securing the cooperation of colonial proprietors and legislatures in implementing it.[6] Public money would now compensate interests in an economy whose trade had helped finance the state.

Mary described being made to work through the night, as the theft of time that belonged to her. ‘My mistress often robbed me too of the hours that belong to sleep.’[7] Section 24 of the 1833 Act placed the compensable loss on the other side of that relationship; it was the ‘Loss of such Services’.[8] ‘Services’ is a quiet word for labour a person had no legal freedom to refuse.

Valuation and inheritance

The sale Mary remembered had separated a family. Later transactions of the same kind now supplied a way to divide the compensation fund. Under s 45, the number of registered enslaved people in each colony was multiplied by the average sale price over the eight years ending on 31 December 1830. Each colony’s share of the £20m followed from those figures; the formula apportioned a fixed fund rather than promising full indemnification.[9] Section 47 then required further classification and the determination of average values within each colony.[10]

A value alone could not identify who should receive an award. The same section required the Commissioners to consider creditors, legatees and annuitants, alongside mortgages, trusts and future interests. It also addressed the appointment of trustees to protect compensation belonging to children or others under a legal disability, and succession to the funds on intestacy.[11]

Entitlement to income did not necessarily carry entitlement to capital; an award might satisfy a secured debt, support an annuity or be held for a future beneficiary. Wealth sustained by enslaved labour could continue to support another generation. A child’s future interest in compensation could be protected in this way. The childhood Mary had described remained outside the losses for which the scheme made provision.

Buying freedom

Even Mary’s own earnings could not secure her release without her owner’s agreement. In Antigua, she had taken in washing and sold provisions, hoping to ‘earn money to buy [her] freedom’. An intermediary approached her owner, but he refused to sell her.[12]

The 1833 Act offered a route past such a refusal for those placed in compulsory ‘apprenticeship’ from 1 August 1834. Under that regime, those who would have been entitled to their labour under slavery retained a right to specified services.[13] Section 8 made early discharge against the employer’s wishes conditional on payment of the appraised value of the future services.[14] For someone taking that route, those future services were days of their own life that still had to be bought.

The public charge

The same settlement placed the cost of compensation on the public purse. The £20m amounted to approximately 40% of annual government expenditure in 1833. In 1835, the government raised £15m through a public loan; a further £5m was provided in government stock.[15]

Section 31 of the 1833 Act charged the annuities, interest, dividends and management expenses to the Consolidated Fund.[16] The cost of honouring interests derived from colonial slavery thus became a charge on general public revenue; the provision neither earmarked a particular tax nor imposed liability on a particular taxpayer. Borrowing avoided collecting the whole sum immediately in taxation, but left open how the burden would fall.

That question had already brought Parliament back to sugar. On 11 June 1833, George Richard Robinson, MP for Worcester, warned that a further duty would reach working families through the price of an everyday purchase. He supported compensation but opposed financing it through further taxes on consumption.[17] Rigby Wason, MP for Ipswich, proposed a tax on property in Britain to fund the government’s plan; his resolution was rejected without a division.[18]

Some radical and working-class objections to taxation carried racial exclusion; they portrayed white British workers as paying for Black freedom while their own exploitation continued. Other voices argued that the £20m should go to enslaved people themselves.[19]

What abolition did not extinguish

Firms also made money from the compensation scheme, collecting awards as agents for a commission, advancing funds at interest or buying claims as principals at a discount and keeping the eventual proceeds.[20] An award paid in government stock could change hands too. A claimant who sold the stock received cash; the purchaser acquired the rights attached to it, while the government remained liable.[21]

In 2018, HM Treasury explained how the 1835 borrowing had entered the gilt programme and ultimately the undated 4% Consolidated Loan. Redemption became possible in 1957 but was not compulsory. The loan was redeemed on 1 February 2015 as part of the decision to redeem the remaining undated gilts.

By then, the compensation awards had long since been paid. The interval, the Treasury explained, reflected the financial instrument rather than the amount borrowed; what was redeemed in 2015 was refinanced public debt.[22]

For the Revenue Bar, Black History Month offers an occasion to read the 1833 Act’s compensation provisions with Mary’s account open beside them. The questions of entitlement, valuation and inheritance remain; so do Mary, Hannah and Dinah.

At the end of the sale, their mother hugged and kissed the girls. They left in different directions; she, Mary recalled, ‘went home with nothing’.[23]

The debt has been redeemed; in the shadow of that settled account, Mary’s words still ask – what is owed to those whose loss never counted?


[1] Mary Prince, The History of Mary Prince, a West Indian Slave, Related by Herself (Thomas Pringle ed, F Westley and A H Davis 1831) 3⁠–⁠4, including the editor’s note identifying Bermuda currency and giving an equivalent of approximately £38 sterling; see also the editor’s preface, iii.

[2] Slavery Abolition Act 1833 (3 & 4 Will 4 c 73), ss 12, 24 and 47. Section 64 excepted East India Company territories, Ceylon and Saint Helena.

[3] Campbell v Hall (1774) 1 Cowp 204, 204⁠–⁠05, 209, 212⁠–⁠14; 98 ER 1045 (KB).

[4] Ernesto Dal Bó and others, ‘Dissecting the Sinews of Power: International Trade and the Rise of Britain’s Fiscal-Military State, 1689⁠–⁠1823’ (2025) 85(2) The Journal of Economic History 336, 356⁠–⁠57 and fig 6.

[5] HC Deb 25 May 1829, vol 21, ‘Sugar Duties Bill’ (speeches of Mr C Grant and the Chancellor of the Exchequer). The online index renders the title as ‘Sugar Deities Bill’. For Grant’s constituency, see History of Parliament, ‘Charles Grant’.

[6] HC Deb 11 June 1833, vol 18, cols 586⁠–⁠87 and 593⁠–⁠94 (Mr Secretary Stanley and Lord Althorp respectively).

[8] 1833 Act, s 24.

[9] Ibid, s 45; Ingrid Jeacle, ‘Calculating a Life: Classification, Valuation and Compensation in the British Abolition of Slavery’ (2023) 36(3) Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 1002, section 6.1 (accepted manuscript 15⁠–⁠17). Section 45 excluded certain prices affected by reservations or conditions.

[10] 1833 Act, s 47; Jeacle (n 9), section 6.2 (accepted manuscript 18⁠–⁠19).

[13] 1833 Act, ss 1⁠–⁠2 and 5⁠–⁠6.

[14] Ibid, ss 7⁠–⁠8. Section 7 allowed voluntary discharge by the employer.

[15] HM Treasury, ‘Freedom of Information Act 2000: Slavery Abolition Act 1833’ (FOI2018/00186, 31 January 2018) 1; Michael D Bennett and Mike Anson, ‘The Compensation Agency Business: London Merchants, Bankers, and the Payment of Slavery Compensation, 1835⁠–⁠46’ (2025) 26(4) Enterprise & Society 1273, 1278⁠–⁠80.

[16] 1833 Act, ss 24 and 31⁠–⁠32.

[17] HC Deb 11 June 1833, vol 18, cols 574⁠–⁠75 (George Richard Robinson, MP for Worcester, and Lord Althorp). Lord Althorp, then Chancellor of the Exchequer, confirmed that the method of financing remained undecided, although an approved grant would have to be made good.

[18] HC Deb 11 June 1833, vol 18, col 598 (Mr Rigby Wason). His resolution concerned the expense of implementing the government’s plan generally. For Wason’s constituency, see UK Parliament, Historic Hansard, ‘Mr Rigby Wason’.

[19] Zach Sell, ‘Compensated Emancipation from the Metropolitan Below: Class, Taxation, and the Slavery Abolition Act (1833)’ (2026) 40(3) Contemporary British History 375, abstract and introduction.

[20] Bennett and Anson (n 15) 1287.

[21] Bennett and Anson (n 15) 1294⁠–⁠95 (sales of government stock).

[22] HM Treasury (n 15) 2.

[23] Prince (n 1) 4.

Categories: Analysis
EDITOR'S PICKstar
Top