Tax Journal

Main purpose, or one of the main purposes

7 June 2018
SPEED READ

The phrase ‘main purpose or one of the main purposes’ is widely used in UK tax law. A person may have more than one main purpose in entering into a transaction, and ‘a main purpose’ is a wider test than ‘the main purpose’. Cases including Snell, Lloyds TSB Equipment Leasing (No. 1) Ltd and Travel Document Service & Ladbroke Group International confirm that a transaction can have more than one main purpose and obtaining a tax advantage can be a main object of a transaction; however, in order for a purpose to be ‘main’ it must have a connotation of importance.

Jackie Wheaton (Moore Stephens) examines the widely-used phrase in UK tax law, particularly in relation to anti-avoidance sections.

The phrase ‘main purpose or one of the main purposes’ is widely used in UK tax law, particularly in the anti-avoidance sections.

For example, the HMRC’s Business Income Manual at BIM60560 refers to the conditions in CTA 2010 s 356OB relating to the corporation tax treatment of certain profits and gains realised from disposals concerned with land in the UK. The provisions apply generally if a person acquiring, holding or developing land realises a profit or gain from a disposal of any land in the UK and any of four conditions is met in relation to the land. Three of these conditions contain a test of whether the ‘main purpose or one of the main purposes’ for acquiring or developing the land, or the property deriving its value from land, was to realise a profit or gain from disposing of the land. Where the conditions are met, the profit or gain is treated as a profit of a trade of dealing in or developing UK land, and arising to the chargeable company or person.

The manual states that the main purpose test is a test of purpose, not of benefit or expectations. It is noted that a person may have more than one main purpose in entering into a transaction, and that ‘a main purpose’ is a wider test than requiring something to be ‘the main purpose’.

There is no definition of ‘main purpose’ in the legislation. HMRC’...

This content is available to magazine subscribers only.

Subscribe now!

Get an annual subscription to Tax Journal  for £456. Have unrestricted access to Taxjournal.com and you'll also receive the print magazine - to make sure you never miss what matters in tax.

When it comes to keeping informed on tax, Tax Journal provides something a little different...

  • Tax Journal prides itself on the calibre of its contributors, and the quality and usefulness of its information.
  • The journal is widely regarded as the best source of insight on business and corporate tax issues. It is relied upon by thousands of leading experts - including those in the professional firms, in industry and at HMRC alike.
  • A subscription provides unrestricted access to this website for cutting edge research on tax, plus the print journal to ensure you never miss what matters.
  • In addition to expert commentary on new developments, Tax Journal provides an archive of 'Back to basics' and 'Practice guides' to help you handle knotty tax issues in practice
  • Plus bespoke tax news and and archive of hundreds of tax case summaries, all specially written by our tax qualifies news and case editors.

What our readers say 

‘What sets it apart is the quality of its contributors.’ - Ken Almand, Tax Adviser, Baker Tilly

‘Tax Journal can always be relied upon to provide articles covering relevant and highly topical issues, but without being too long or onerous.’ - Jennie Rimmer, Head of Tax, Aspen Re

‘My favourite aspects are the Speed Reads, the Back to Basics articles and the case summaries.’ - Tanya Richards, Director of Tax, British Sky Broadcasting Group plc

‘Tax Journal is at the cutting edge of tax legislative changes and HMRC proposed initiatives. It leads the way in informed debate.’ - Aileen Barry, Director, DLA Piper UK LLP

‘For me, Tax Journal is an essential read – not only to get a feel for what experts in all areas of tax are talking about but also to check what is being said in the area in which I specialise.’ - Jason Collins, Tax Partner, Pinsent Masons